Forgotten Hill: Puppeteer

Having just escaped the strange house in the hill, Jimmy Larson returns to his car, only to find Josephine Taylor missing. The only clues as to her whereabouts are a trail of blood leading down the road and a ticket to the Puppet Theater. Resolving to rescue her, Jimmy sets out on foot to the Theater. Upon entering, the usher taking his ticket - who shockingly appears to be a living puppet - mentions something about a "new performer" debuting tonight. Exploring the Theater, he encounters a morbidly obese man in the waiting area who has also been transformed into a living puppet. Jimmy enters the Theater itself, only to be blocked by a man in a cat-like mask and top hat who seems obsessed with gambling, and will not let Jimmy pass unless he can win a game of cards.