Looking for games like Penumbra: Black Plague? Penumbra: Black Plague (2008) is listed on IGDB under Indie, Adventure and Puzzle. Here are 10 games IGDB marks as similar to it.
10 games

Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs
2013PCSwitchPS4+3
Amnesia: Rebirth
2020PCSwitch 2PS5+4
Bendy and the Dark Revival
2022PCPS5Series X|S+5
Cold Fear
2005PCPS2XBOX
Imscared
2012PCAndroid
Madison
2022PCPS5Series X|S+3
Maid of Sker
2020PCPS5Series X|S+5
Metro Exodus
2019PCPS5Series X|S+5
Penumbra: Overture
2007PCLinuxMac
White Night
2015PCSwitchPS4+3
Which games count as similar comes from IGDB's similar-games data. Sorted by average CritScore member rating, then by number of member ratings. No one pays to appear here. Games with no member ratings yet follow in alphabetical order.
CritScore is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any publisher, developer or platform holder named here.

