10 games

Fairy Godmother Stories: Dark Deal
2020PCMac
Hidden Expedition: Devil's Triangle
2009PCAndroidiOS+1
Hotel 626
2008browser

Mystery Case Files: 13th Skull
2011PCMac
Mystery Case Files: Huntsville
2005PCLinuxMac
Mystery Case Files: Ravenhearst
2006PC3DSNDS+2
Mystery Legends: Sleepy Hollow
2008PCiOSMac
Uru: Ages Beyond Myst
2003PC
Weird Park: Scary Tales
2012PCMobile
Which games count as similar comes from IGDB's similar-games data. Sorted by average CritScore member rating, then by number of member ratings. No one pays to appear here. Games with no member ratings yet follow in alphabetical order.
